Will the US be able to prop up its domestic semiconductor industry in a way that rivals China's -- not including Taiwan -- in the next five years?
Will the US be able to prop up its domestic semiconductor industry in a way that rivals China's -- not including Taiwan -- in the next five years?
➕
Plus
43
Ṁ3704
2027
75%
chance

This resolves to YES if China -- not including Taiwan -- isn't obviously way better at making the most modern chips by five years from this day.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00


Sort by:
predictedYES 1y

Intel just announced 4nm is shipping in December, 18A (1.8nm) still on track for next year, featuring gate all around and backside power delivery.

1y

Less than 1% of subsidy rolled out, and mostly to labs not fabs. Opening of TSMC facility in Arizona not going well. Hard to hire and conflicts with local unions. https://twitter.com/kevinsxu/status/1706018257604403218?t=UaiI0WvWxnKZwfHJIBYLuw&s=19

predictedYES 2y

Also Tim Cook just said they are comitting to buying from TSMC's first Arizona fab when it opens in 2024 in order to diversify their supply chain. And it's being reported that that one will be N4 process now, it was previously reported as being N7.

2y

thought about it a little longer and bought more. Building fabs is very hard and takes a long time.

predictedYES 2y

@Adam Especially when you can’t purchase the equipment you need but instead need to reinvent it. They are trapped in 2016 indefinitely.

2y

taking the over on US bureaucracy dysfunction at 5:1 odds seems like a good deal to me.

2y

Are you going to exclude Taiwan even if China successfully invades it?

predictedYES 2y

@Yev Invading Taiwan will be the end of TSMC. They will no doubt sabotage the infrastructure and even if they didn't, China doesn't have anyone to operate them and you can't just walk in and read the manual.

2y

@Yev Yep. They have to bring the capabilities to mainland for it to count.

predictedYES 2y
2y

Intel and SMIC are currently both 3 years behind TSMC. Both started shipping 7nm in 2021 compared to 2018 for TSMC, and Intel says they'll be shipping 4nm in 2023, which is comparable to TSMC's 5nm from 2020. Intel is building two new fabs in Arizona that are targeting leading edge 20A (2nm) production in 2025, while SMIC is being sanctioned by all their machine suppliers. China now has to develop their own machines to replace ASML's EUV machines and others which will set them back several more years.

predictedYES 2y

Oh it looks like the Netherlands blocked ASML from selling EUV machines to China a few years ago, so China won't have a EUV machine to reverse engineer and copy. Without EUV their 5nm node will be much more difficult and expensive than competitors with EUV, and they probably won't be able to push past 5nm. I'm not sure if getting an ASML engineer to steal the plans for EUV like SMIC reportedly did for TSMC 7nm will be possible.

predictedYES 2y

A couple days ago I looked and wasn't able to find a US brokerage that will let me short Chinese stocks.

2y

99.9999 percent chance this resolves YES. China is trapped in 2016 now following new US export controls. China can't reinvent both the equipment and the chips in 5 or even 15 years.

2y

LOL, can you name one advanced chip China is better at making today?! No you cannot.

2y

I'll take the pessimist bet at 4-1, if literally everyone else in this market is going the other way.

TSMC USA foundries are "I'll believe it when I see it". Foundries are notoriously fiddly, require manufacturing talent that's absent or very expensive in the US, and TSMC's presence in Taiwan is geopolitically important.

Not that China will have an easy time, but they can throw engineers at the problem at a scale the US will not.

I mostly expect that in 5 years US semi goes the way of most state megaprojects: over budget and under-delivering. And China will be making some headway on EUV, but still meaningfully lagging TSMC.

2y

wow, 80%? y'all are optimistic. Is it because you think Chinese people who are good at semiconductors will want to leave an increasingly nationalistic China? Is it because you think the US is gonna fix its high skill immigration problems for semiconductor talent? Some other reason?

predictedYES 2y

@RuthGraceWong SMIC, the main Chinese semiconductor manufacturer, has been sanctioned by the US over stealing process documentation from TSMC. In the short term, ASML, which is the only manufacturer of EUV lithography tech, is banned from selling or providing knowledge to Chinese companies (https://www.msn.com/en-xl/news/other/tech-war-asml-lam-research-rush-to-pull-us-engineers-out-of-china-chip-operations-as-fresh-us-restrictions-kick-in/ar-AA12WbGQ). SMIC has also demonstrated that it takes a long time to duplicate processes from TSMC. SMIC just started shipping simple 7 nm chips, which puts them about 4 years behind state-of-the-art. Meanwhile, TSMC is planning to build a 5 nm foundry in Arizona by 2024, and Intel says it will be shipping 5 nm Meteor Lake chips in early 2023. So will SMIC be able to develop a 5 nm process in five years, while under US sanctions? 20% seems reasonable.

Will the US be able to prop up its domestic semiconductor industry in a way that rivals China's -- not including Taiwan -- in the next five years?, 8k, beautiful, illustration, trending on art station, picture of the day, epic composition

What is this?

What is Manifold?
Manifold is the world's largest social prediction market.
Get accurate real-time odds on politics, tech, sports, and more.
Win cash prizes for your predictions on our sweepstakes markets! Always free to play. No purchase necessary.
Are our predictions accurate?
Yes! Manifold is very well calibrated, with forecasts on average within 4 percentage points of the true probability. Our probabilities are created by users buying and selling shares of a market.
In the 2022 US midterm elections, we outperformed all other prediction market platforms and were in line with FiveThirtyEight’s performance. Many people who don't like trading still use Manifold to get reliable news.
How do I win cash prizes?
Manifold offers two market types: play money and sweepstakes.
All questions include a play money market which uses mana Ṁ and can't be cashed out.
Selected markets will have a sweepstakes toggle. These require sweepcash S to participate and winners can withdraw sweepcash as a cash prize. You can filter for sweepstakes markets on the browse page.
Redeem your sweepcash won from markets at
S1.00
→ $1.00
, minus a 5% fee.
Learn more.
© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules